While most professional reviewers tend to use a 4 star scale, I’ve opted for the 5 Star system because it allows for more detail in accuracy. In other words, I can more precisely pinpoint where a movie stands against other movies without being misleading. For example, Roger Ebert gave both Spider-Man 2 and The Dark Knight a 4 star review which would lead the reader to believe they are on par with one another. THEY ARE NOT. On my scale, I would award Spider-Man 2 4 stars, indicating it as a successfully solid, though not entirely original film and The Dark Knight 5 stars indicating a wholly original masterpiece.
Also, websites that review movies tend to go with a 10 point scale issuing reviews like fractions (ex. 8/10). If you take into account my use of half a star (ex. ***1/2 = 3 and a half stars), then I am essentially following suit. The reason why I don’t completely convert is that, honestly, I don’t like the way fractions look. Music reviews are often done with 5 stars and it just looks better and more professional than saying “I give this film a 2/10.”
As for those who use the point scales (ex. 5.2/10.0), they can go fuck themselves. I don’t know what 5.2 means and if anyone says they do, they’re lying. Those scores are arbitrary and tell readers nothing. Naturally you find these on the most pretentious websites like pitchfork. For my opinion on pitchfork.com, please refer to the previous 2 sentences.
And so, to further give you, the people, a better idea of how I will be reviewing movies, here is a brief rundown on what my star system means:
0 = zero stars. A movie so bad, it should have never been made and can never be redeemed. (ex. Dragonball: Evolution)
* = one star. A movie in which nothing goes right and can’t even be appreciated on an ironic basis. (ex. Peter Jackson’s King Kong)
*1/2 = one and a half stars. A movie that has a good premise but unbelievably bad execution. (ex. Ghost Rider)
** = two stars. A movie that is “so bad it’s good”. They are very watchable but can’t be called “good” per se (ex. Plan 9 From Outer Space)
**1/2 = two and a half stars. A movie that can’t be defined as wholly good or wholly terrible. These tend to be movies of all style, no substance. (ex. Transformers)
*** = three stars. A movie that is enjoyable but contains many flaws. (ex. The Exorcist: The Beginning)
***1/2 = three and a half stars. A movie that has many good elements but too many bad ones to garner a true recommendation. These movies tend to be the few redeeming blockbusters (ex. X-Men Origins: Wolverine.)
**** = four stars. A solid and truly pleasing movie with very few flaws that simply lacks enough originality to get a higher rating. (ex. Spider-Man 2)
****1/2 = four and a half stars. A great film that has something small holding it back from being called a masterpiece. (ex. Sunshine)
***** = five stars. An undisputed masterpiece. These types of films are wholly original and go on to influence the way movies are made. (ex. Pulp Fiction)



























